Top 10 Best Unique Restaurants Near Toms River, New Jersey

Toms River, New Jersey, a charming town known for its proximity to the Jersey Shore, boasts a thriving culinary scene that offers a diverse range of restaurants. From fine dining to quirky local spots, this town has something for everyone. Below is a list of the top 10 unique restaurants near Toms River, each offering a distinct atmosphere and exceptional cuisine.

1. The Serenity Café

Located on Fischer Boulevard, The Serenity Café is a hidden gem with a tranquil ambiance that perfectly complements its fusion menu. Combining American and Asian influences, this restaurant prides itself on fresh ingredients and creative dishes. Popular options include the coconut shrimp and the filet mignon. Serenity Café also features an extensive wine list and a variety of craft cocktails. What sets this restaurant apart is its zen-like decor and relaxed atmosphere, making it the perfect place for a peaceful dining experience.

• Address: 2008 Route 37 East, Toms River, NJ 08753
• Specialties: Fusion cuisine, seafood, steak
• Why it’s unique: The combination of Asian-American fusion dishes and a serene ambiance

2. Il Giardinello Ristorante

For an authentic taste of Italy, Il Giardinello Ristorante on Hooper Avenue is the place to be. This family-owned restaurant offers a warm, old-world charm with a menu full of Italian classics. Whether it’s their house-made gnocchi, veal dishes, or seafood specialties, every dish is meticulously prepared. The intimate setting, complete with white tablecloths and dim lighting, adds to the overall charm of Il Giardinello.

• Address: 1232 Hooper Ave., Toms River, NJ 08753
• Specialties: Traditional Italian fare, seafood
• Why it’s unique: authentic Italian recipes passed down through generations, creating a homey yet elegant dining experience.

3. Shogun Legacy

For sushi lovers, Shogun Legacy in the neighboring town of Brick offers an elevated dining experience. This modern Japanese restaurant serves both traditional sushi and innovative rolls. The decor is sleek, and the presentation of dishes is artistic, adding a layer of sophistication to your meal. A local favorite is the Spicy Tuna Crunch Roll and their signature Hibachi dishes, where chefs cook right at your table, entertaining guests with culinary skills.

• Address: 1659 Route 88 West, Brick, NJ 08724
• Specialties: sushi, hibachi, Japanese cuisine
• Why it’s unique: Hibachi-style cooking at your table, coupled with a stylish atmosphere

4. The River Market

Located on Main Street, The River Market offers a farm-to-table dining experience, focusing on seasonal, locally sourced ingredients. The menu rotates frequently depending on what’s fresh, ensuring every visit is a new adventure. Expect to find dishes like roasted pork belly, hand-rolled pastas, and fresh salads. The modern, rustic decor with reclaimed wood accents adds to the farm-to-table theme, making it a chic but casual dining spot.

• Address: 33 Main Street, Toms River, NJ 08753
• Specialties: farm-to-table, seasonal dishes
• Why it’s unique: The focus on locally sourced ingredients and constantly changing menu

5. Capone’s Gourmet Pizza & Pasta

Capone’s Gourmet Pizza & Pasta is more than just a pizza joint—it’s an experience. Capone’s, which draws inspiration from the Prohibition era, combines an authentic Italian setting with a speakeasy feel. Their thin-crust gourmet pizzas are a crowd favorite, as are the house-made pastas. With a focus on fresh ingredients and unique flavor combinations, Capone’s offers a playful take on traditional Italian food.

• Address: 17 Washington St., Toms River, NJ 08753
• Specialties: Gourmet pizza, pasta, Italian
• Why it’s unique: A prohibition-era speakeasy theme, offering a fun and nostalgic dining experience

6. A Thyme for All Seasons

A Thyme for All Seasons is a small, intimate restaurant offering a rotating seasonal menu. Located off Fischer Boulevard, this family-run eatery focuses on using the best local ingredients. Signature dishes include pan-seared scallops, duck breast, and their famous homemade desserts. The charming, cottage-like setting creates a cozy dining experience perfect for a romantic evening out or a small celebration.

• Address: 63 Fischer Blvd., Toms River, NJ 08753
• Specialties: seasonal, local cuisine
• Why it’s unique: Focus on seasonality, local produce, and a cozy, intimate atmosphere.

7. Xina

For a unique take on Asian cuisine, Xina on Route 37 is a must-visit. This Asian fusion restaurant combines flavors from China, Japan, and Thailand, creating a menu that is both eclectic and delicious. From sushi to Thai curries, Xina offers a variety of options, but their seafood dishes stand out, especially the lobster pad Thai. The waterfront location and modern decor add to the upscale yet relaxed dining experience.

• Address: 3430 NJ-37, Toms River, NJ 08753
• Specialties: Asian fusion, seafood
• Why it’s unique: waterfront location and diverse Asian-inspired menu

8. Artisan’s Brewery and Italian Grill

Combining the best of both worlds—craft beer and Italian food—Artisan’s Brewery and Italian Grill is a unique spot near Toms River. Known for its in-house brewed beers and extensive menu, Artisan’s offers a laid-back atmosphere perfect for a casual night out. Their woodfired pizzas are a hit, as are their hearty pasta dishes. The on-site brewery adds an element of freshness to their beer selection, making it a must-visit for craft beer enthusiasts.

• Address: 1171 Hooper Ave., Toms River, NJ 08753
• Specialties: Italian cuisine, craft beer
• Why it’s unique: Combination of freshly brewed beers and authentic Italian dishes

9. Shut up and eat!

Quirky, fun, and full of personality, Shut Up and Eat! on Main Street is a breakfast and lunch spot that feels like a throwback to the 1950s. The decor is filled with memorabilia, and the servers wear pajamas, adding to the whimsical experience. The menu is comfort food at its best, with oversized pancakes, creative sandwiches, and diner-style dishes. Whether you’re in the mood for a hearty breakfast or a casual lunch, Shut Up and Eat! is sure to put a smile on your face.

• Address: 804 Main St., Toms River, NJ 08753
• Specialties: breakfast, diner food, sandwiches
• Why it’s unique: Playful atmosphere with pajama-clad staff and a retro diner vibe

10. Blend on Main

Located a bit further out in Manasquan, Blend on Main is worth the drive for those looking for a fine dining experience with a local touch. The restaurant’s focus is on New American cuisine, with a strong emphasis on farm-to-table practices. The interior is upscale yet welcoming, with dishes like lamb chops, seafood risotto, and a selection of freshly prepared desserts. The chef’s tasting menu is a favorite among regulars, offering a curated experience with wine pairings.

• Address: 152 Main St., Manasquan, NJ 08736
• Specialties: New American, farm-to-table
• Why it’s unique: Chef-driven, farm-to-table concept with an upscale dining experience

Conclusion

Toms River, New Jersey, offers a wealth of unique restaurants that cater to a variety of tastes and preferences. Whether you’re in the mood for fine dining, quirky local spots, or international flavors, the area has something for everyone. From serene cafes to bustling fusion restaurants, these 10 establishments represent the best of Toms River’s diverse culinary landscape. Each offers something special, ensuring that your dining experience is one to remember.

Also read OKC Thunder vs. New Orleans Pelicans Match Player Stats